Archives for August 2018

To achieve the benefits outlined last week, we must follow some basic guidelines for successful group discussions in the classroom. Giving students the floor to freely discuss any subject without guidelines or ground rules can quickly lead to chaos. Quality group discussions don’t just happen; they require thoughtful planning and preparation. Here then, are guidelines for successful group discussions to try in your classroom.

Plan Your Outcome

Start your planning with determining what it is that you want the students to take away from the discussion.  For example, if your lesson is about the fall of man, then you might wish to focus the discussion on how we can easily succumb to the sin of pride. You might begin with questions that allow students to identify prideful words or actions of historical or celebrity figures. Subsequent questions would switch the focus to potential areas of personal pride. The takeaway lesson might be “It’s easy to see the pride in others but spotting it in ourselves requires self-examination.”

Generate Interest

Introduce the topic via a short video or song, a Bible story or parable, or just a question. This is an opportunity to get the students’ attention and generate interest in the discussion that will follow. In our previous example of a lesson on the fall of man, you might want to begin with a YouTube video of Muhammad Ali’s famous “Rumble in the Jungle” speech. Keep in mind that you would need to set up the video with some context for Generation Z.

Use Handouts

A worksheet gives students an opportunity to quietly read, reflect and answer questions before the discussion begins. Handouts also provide a roadmap for the discussion. Try to incorporate questions that solicit opinions where there is no right or wrong answer. These are usually better suited to getting the conversation started, since no one is worried about answering incorrectly. The purpose of the discussion is to connect the lesson to the students’ everyday life. So, following our previous example, we might begin with questions like, “In the video we just watched, which of the claims made by Muhammad Ali might lead a person to believe he is proud?” Follow up with more thought-provoking questions. You could list examples and ask students to identify whether each represents healthy or excessive pride.

Establish Boundaries

These are deal breakers as far as I’m concerned.  The class needs to understand that group discussions will only happen when done so respectfully.  Be sure to articulate these rules before beginning the discussion.

• No one will be forced to talk, but all are expected to participate. Some students may not feel comfortable sharing their thoughts, and that’s okay. However, everyone in the group is expected to complete the handout, and if they’re not sharing, they need to be listening.
• No judgment zone. We are here to discuss and gain insight, not to put each other down or call people out. We don’t have to agree with one another about everything, but personal attacks or jabs will not be tolerated.
• Only one person speaks at a time. This is simple common courtesy. Every person in the group deserves to be heard
• Stay on subject. Discussions can veer off-subject rapidly. This can be a distraction, in which case you want to shut down the discussion and steer it back to the subject at hand. Then again, if this is something the students are genuinely concerned about, it may warrant further or future discussion.
• Questions are always welcome. Assuming that time permits, you can encourage students to ask questions, as this promotes further dialogue.

Incorporate Scripture

As Catechists, we should refer to Scripture whenever possible.  In our example of a discussion about the sin of pride, you might ask the students to read the Magnificat (Luke 1: 46-55).  Mary is the model of humility. Even after learning that she was to be the mother of our Savior, she remained a humble servant. Ask the students to point to specific instances in the passage where the Blessed Mother expresses her humility. Including Scripture helps to reinforce that students should look to Scripture for answers to questions they have.

Group Size

One final, but important, consideration – your class size. If you class is large, consider breaking into smaller groups, so that every student can share in the discussion. You can ask adult volunteers to pitch in as group leaders. This is a great way to get parents or your parish Youth Minister involved.

With proper planning, your group discussions will get your students thinking and talking about their faith life.

© 2018 Catechist’s Aide

As a Middle School Catechist, I have found group discussions to be one of the most effective teaching tools. If you haven’t considered leading a group discussion in your classroom, here are 5 reasons you should.

Encourages Dialogue

These days religion can be a touchy subject to bring up, even among adults. It’s especially true for middle school students, who tend to be socially insecure. They might avoid bringing up topics which they perceive would set them apart from the crowd. Discussion groups give students an opportunity to discuss important issues of faith with their peers without singling them out.  There is also the hope that, as they become more at ease participating in these discussions, they will feel comfortable discussing such topics outside of the classroom. For many young teens, group discussions become the first step in articulating their faith to themselves and others.

Engages Students

I know that I get tired of the sound of my voice.  So, I imagine my students aren’t keen on hearing me talk for an hour or more each week. A class filled with only instruction can lead to students who are at worst, completely zoned out, or at best, merely going through the motions. Adding group discussions can bring new energy into the classroom.  Hearing another voice – especially one of their peers – can result in engaging the students in a way that I can’t do on my own.

Demonstrates Community

The essence of the Catholic faith is communion. God gave us the Church because He wanted us to be redeemed together, not alone.  God himself, in the Trinity, is a communion – an eternal relationship of love.  We, who are made in His image, are made for relationship, not only with our Creator but with each other. These discussion groups, in a small way, help to demonstrate the importance of community, and how we are to advance the kingdom of God – together.

Provides Feedback

I sometimes question how much of the material presented in class students retain. Group discussions provide useful feedback for the Catechist, such as how much of the information students are picking up. More importantly, it allows the Catechist to see the degree of students’ understanding.  Group discussions also provide feedback for the student, by communicating the ideas or information from the lesson that are most important.

Makes a Connection

Thoughts about Faith, Church, or God may seldom enter into our students’ minds outside of Sunday Mass or Religious Ed class. Group discussions give students an opportunity to realize that their faith life extends beyond the confines of the Church building. This is the greatest gift that we, as Catechists, can bring to our students. Connecting the lesson with their personal lives helps students see that what they learn in the classroom has a real-life application.  It’s similar to what St. James said in his epistle:

Be doers of the word and not hearers only, deluding yourselves. For if anyone is a hearer of the word and not a doer, he is like a man who looks at his own face in a mirror. He sees himself, then goes off and promptly forgets what he looked like. But the one who peers into the perfect law of freedom and perseveres, and is not a hearer who forgets but a doer who acts, such a one shall be blessed in what he does.  (James 1: 22-25)

There are many other benefits to group discussions. It can help students develop confidence when speaking in groups, teaches them that their thoughts and opinions have value, helps them appreciate that not everyone shares their view, and provides an opportunity to learn how to disagree with someone respectfully. With all these benefits, I hope you will give group discussions a try in your class this year. Be sure to check back next week for the keys to making your group discussions successful.

© 2018 Catechist’s Aide